AutoCAD vs SolidWorks – Which CADD Software is Better for Modeling, Simulation, and Analysis

LinkedIn
Facebook
Twitter
Email
Print
drive, technology, transmission-1545287.jpg

Table of Contents

Computer-Aided Design or CAD is the design process using computers to help create, draft, modify, analyze and optimize a design. The use of CAD software helps enhance the efficacy of the design process, the quality of the production and provides a more effective means to communicate during the design stage. CAD software is extensively used for 2D drafting and 3D modeling in various fields – from automotive to aerospace manufacturing, electric circuit design to Building Information Modelling, and many research areas like computational fluids and robotics. CAD has not just replaced tedious manual drafting but the inbuilt features like material properties, finite element method, bills of material, and dimensioning have merged creative and technical aspects of engineering. The long tiresome process of solving equations and repeating them for the entire diagram has also been replaced by features provided by CAD software. Features like simulation and finite element method enable engineers to test their design on the computer and save money that otherwise would be wasted during prototype testing.

Several CAD software are available that offer a number of different features to help create models more efficiently. Some of the widely used CAD software are:

  • AutoCAD
  • SolidWorks
  • PTC Creo
  • Catia
  • Siemens NX

In this article, we will compare the most widely used software in the mechanical industry – AutoCAD and SolidWorks.

AutoCAD

AutoCAD is a product of Autodesk Company and was launched in Dec 1982. AutoCAD is employed by architects, engineers, and urban planners worldwide for 2D Drafting. The toolkit available in AutoCAD helps design a majority of geometries efficiently and productively. Although the 3D modeling features are available in AutoCAD, yet the software is mostly used for its superior 2D drafting tools. The file format of AutoCAD is a .dwg file.

SolidWorks

SolidWorks is a 3D modeling software developed by Dassault Systèmes and launched in Nov 1995. It is used widely by engineers and designers to develop 3D solid models and assemblies. The parametric feature-based modeling offered by SolidWorks is preferred by engineers and designers to validate and modify their designs. SolidWorks also enable designers to reverse engineering their design. The associated file is .slddrw, .sldprt and .sldasm.

Comparison Between AutoCAD and SolidWorks

  • CAD software use different techniques of modelling – the more common ones are parametric feature-based modelling and direct modelling. Parametric modelling is like a computer program – it executes every command line before moving ahead. Any error in a line makes the entire program defective. Parametric modelling develops a model using every parameter like geometry dimensions, constraints and relations between parts. It is a history-based model. The designer has to work through a tree. Changes made in the model have to go through the entire tree. However, with direct modelling, the designer does not have to worry about parameters and history tree. It is a history-free model. He can modify the design in real-time without bothering about previous constraints and part relations. While direct modelling is easy to use and does not require a long learning curve, parametric modelling, however, gives designer more control over their design. Designing variations of their model is easier with parametric modelling since the designer is familiar with the parts and history of the model. Keeping track of tree also gives them more control over modifications and functionality during the production phase.

AutoCAD works using the direct modeling principle while SolidWorks makes use of parametric feature modeling.

  • AutoCAD has tools that are extensively built for 2D drafting, although it does offer 3D modelling tools, they are not suitable for advanced assemblies. Designing a complex 3D model can be done easily using SolidWorks. Using the feature of SolidWorks, to describe constraints and relations between parts of the assembly, is a more efficient way of creating a 3D model. AutoCAD is preferred by designers and planners to create 2D drafts and layout plans of different structures and geometries due to its industry-specific command tools.
  • The inbuilt simulation features available in SolidWorks have made it a popular choice among engineers especially mechanical and aerospace engineers. The real-time testing for stress limitations of a model, the deformations and material failure tests and fatigue simulations help the engineers save investment during prototype production. This feature is absent in AutoCAD.
  • Another important testing feature for engineers is computational fluid dynamics, especially when designing a model that interacts with fluid. This feature helps while improving the aerodynamics of a car or a rocket. It is also important while dealing with turbo engines and jets. SolidWorks equip engineers with computational fluid dynamics testing features while AutoCAD does not provide this feature.
  • AutoCAD has built-in industry-specific tools that provide an efficient designing experience. These tools are used by architects and interior designers to create layouts efficiently. MEP tools are also available in AutoCAD. However, for machine-related designing, SolidWorks is an effective option. It helps in Computer-Aided Engineering and the use of Computer Numerical Control (CNC) machines. The preciseness and accuracy that can be achieved using SolidWorks controlled CNC machine are vital in designing critical components to be used in machines.
  • SolidWorks requires great experience and learning to become adept and proficient at it. The extensive features available for design, testing, computer-aided manufacturing require a deep understanding of the software. However, the large online community available for any guidance can help beginners to develop their understanding. From the online presence of the members, SolidWorks seems like the most used software for CAD designs.
  • AutoCAD is available for both windows and mac. SolidWorks, however, is not available for mac and can be used only on windows.
  • The free cloud storage available for AutoCAD users is a benefit for individual who want to access their files from different computers or fear that their data might be lost. With SolidWorks, you have to buy a cloud subscription to enjoy its benefits.


Summary

 AutoCADSolidWorks
ApplicationExtensive 2D Drafting Tools Limited 3D FunctionalityExtensive 3D Modelling Tools Limited 2D Functionality
Modeling TechniqueDirect ModelingParametric Modeling
SimulationNot AvailableAvailable
Computational Fluid DynamicsNot AvailableAvailable
Used ByArchitects, Urban Planners and Electrical EngineersMechanical Engineers, Aerospace and Aeronautical Engineers
AvailabilityWindows and MacWindows only